sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionsblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLot

What is your views on Mahatma Gandhi's politics? email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 83/100. excellence7 (1051)3 months ago

The great Gandhi used non-violence as a principle to win and he attained success. Do you think the principles of Mahatma Gandhi can be applied in nowadays politics? Are the principles of Mahatma Gandhi still valued in the world?

 
 
politics
sponsors
Jesus Loves You
Here is a prayer that can change your life.
www.Jesus2020.com

Cooperation Info
Learn How Compromising Prevents Conflicts From Escalating.
RevolutionHealth.com

Gandhi
Browse a huge selection now. Find exactly what you want today.
www.ebay.com

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  gandhi, peace, economics, cooperation, gentlemen
 
1. myLot reputation of 80/100. tigertang (1386)   3 months ago

I think it depends on the situation. The Mahatma is rightly idealised in India because he managed to get Independence from the British through non-violent means. Although India's Independence was in actual fact not that NON violent, things could have been worse and unlike China, India has managed to remain a functioning democracy where it's people, even the poorest peasents have the right to tell its politicians to get stuffed. And now, India's economy is growing so there are reasons to celebrate.

People who followed his examples have done well. Look at Nelson Mandela who managed to get South Africa free of arpatheid with minimal bloodshed or Martin Luthor.

However, we have to look at the context that the Mahatma worked in. He lead 300 million plus Indians against 100,000 Englishmen. The 100,000 Englishmen could not rule the 300 million Indians because the 300 million outnumbered them and simply refused to cooperate. Imagine if the situation had been reveresed. In Tibet, the Dalai Lama is trying Gandhi's techniques but it's 6 million Tibetans against 1 billion Chinese, and unlike the gentlemanly British who could not stand the sight of their own people behaving badly against non-violent protestors, the Beijing government has no qualms shooting unarmed demonstrators, even to the International media if need be.

Secondly, the Mahatma's economic policies were a disaster. They encouraged India to become "Self-Sufficient" and India was shut out from the global economy for decades, keeping people poor and forcing them to swallow inferior goods. India has started boom ever since it opened its economy.


myLot reputation of 83/100. excellence7 (1051)  3 months ago

I agree with you but frankly Mahatma Gandhi's principles were indeed justified for that time. And the British had to accept defeat because the whole Indian population were motivated to chase out the British and following the Mahatma's principles, it was a success! I would have really wish that all politics in the world incorporate Gandhi's principles in their governments.


myLot reputation of 80/100. tigertang (1386)  3 months ago

I don't think I was being desrespectful to Gandhi. If I was, I appologise. I think the Mahatma did a fabulous job and coming from Southeast Asia, I owe a debt to India's independence movement because if India had not fought for Independence in the manner that it did, the British might still have tried to keep onto their colonies in Southeast Asia. However, they were so worn down by their failure to keep India, they were willing to let their other colonies go without that much of a fight.

However, I do stand by what I said when I argued that he was right for his times and situation. He could do what he did because of where he was and when he was opperating. Non violence worked against the British and he was leading the majority. Nelson Mandela used non violence brilliantly in South Africa because the Blacks outnumbered the Whites - there was no way they could have killed everyone to keep the majority down if they simply did not want it to be kept down.

This is less effective when you are in the minority though. Dalai Lama has been pursuing cultural freedome for Tibet in a Non violent way but geopolitics are such that "righteousness" loses out to a billion consumers and cheap labour.


myLot reputation of 83/100. excellence7 (1051)  3 months ago

I now agree with you because majority wins!

Jesus Loves You Here is a prayer that can change your life. www.Jesus2020.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 72/100. iftikharsumn (819)   3 months ago

I have heard about gandhi but don't know about his politics,

Cooperation Info Learn How Compromising Prevents Conflicts From Escalating. RevolutionHealth.com
 
3. senjacob (51)   3 months ago

yes,non-violence is the best way to success our life.
gandhi is a great leader and he does follows good principles to save our nation ..

Gandhi Browse a huge selection now. Find exactly what you want today. www.ebay.com
 
sponsors
Peace Sign Lapel Pin
Handcrafted in fine pewter in the U. S. Makes a great gift. Hundreds of original designs to choose from. Visit our Web site.
www.lapelpinplanet.com

Peace Symbol Products from Peace Please
Peace Please Peace Symbol t-shirts, buttons, bumper stickers, tote, jewelry and more, plus a peace forum to add your thoughts to. Proceeds go to help peace and coexistence organizations.
www.peaceplease.com

Choose Success And Wealth Will Follow
Average People By Choosing To Succeed Make Multiple 6 Figure Incomes.
freedom-prosperity-lifestyle.com

similar discussions
Do you think Gandhi a saint?
I've heard oh so many people saying that Gandhi was a great man.Other people say he was a saint.I'd...
father of my nation
he is a person with lots and lots of good things and also have the courge to speake true that was...
Nonresistance
It has been said that nonresistance is the key to the greatest power in the universe, and that what...
Ghandi Quote
My favorite quote is by Mahatma Ghandi.... "Be the change you want to see in the world" My...
the symbol of AHINSA
he always teached good thought throughout his life
why Mahatma Gandhi became a idel person?what did he do for india?
I am proud to tell he is my country and he did everything for his nation and he used to implement...
sponsors
Peace Sign Lapel Pin
Handcrafted in fine pewter in the U. S. Makes a great gift. Hundreds of original designs to choose from. Visit our Web site.
www.lapelpinplanet.com
Peace Symbol Products from Peace Please
Peace Please Peace Symbol t-shirts, buttons, bumper stickers, tote, jewelry and more, plus a peace forum to add your thoughts to. Proceeds go to help peace and coexistence organizations.
www.peaceplease.com
Choose Success And Wealth Will Follow
Average People By Choosing To Succeed Make Multiple 6 Figure Incomes.
freedom-prosperity-lifestyle.com
Sale on Gentleman Cologne by Givenchy
All online orders shipped within 24 hours. Bargain basement prices on popular designer perfumes and colognes. (Shipping to USA and Canada Only).
www.dolceaime.com
Bed and Breakfast.com
Peace With-Inn on Bed and Breakfast.com. Find information on over 27,000 properties on Bed and Breakfast.com. Guest reviews, maps, photos, gift certificates and more.
www.bedandbreakfast.com
how to be a gentleman
Skirts, Blouses, Dresses, and a complete line of accessories.
www.ladiesemporium.com
myLot population: 136,831
privacy | terms | about myLot | legal | contact | FAQs | RSS | guidelines | advertise with us    ©2008 myLot®. All Rights Reserved.