The Notebook or the Titanic?

The titanic was a good movie in terms of showing people about the disaster, but I thought the 'love story' in it was ... well ... pathetic. Barely met and she's going to leave with him? There's no realism involved, which totally ruined it for me.

Now, The Notebook on the other hand, I loved. It was the perfect picture of the love/ hate relationship most couples actually have, and that everything isn't always roses. The Notebook is one of only two or three romance movies I actually like. A Walk To Remember is on other one.

That is a tough one! I will go with the Notebook! Have you read the next part? The wedding is great! noah is at his best! An Allie is a beautiful swan! You must read it if you have not!

The Notebook is my favourtie romantic movie. Its a pure modern classic. I cried around 100 times throughout that movie and I still think about it. That movie is every girl's fairytale and I think every girl deserves a guy like that. Whoever made that movie is a genious and is swimming in the money right now!

To be perfectly honest I can't either. Each movie is a sad & very touching love story. Both also have tragic endings & both have excellent actors & actresses. I guess you can say that both movies touch your heart in different ways. So my choice is to not choose at all LOL. I like them both in different ways. Sorry I know that doesn't help you much, but it's the best I can do LOL.

The Notebook was a lifetime love affair.
If Jack had survived the Titanic, what were the chances he'd have stayed with Rose for their entire lives? Be honest.

The Notebook...definately the Notebook...It is a beautiful love story...and the fact that the live happily ever after...and when they are old and grey,he still loves her and talks to her and waits for her to rememeber him is the most touching thing ever...I cried so hard at the end of that movie...It is probably my most favorite romantic movie ever...

I would have to say as far as romance goes, The Notebook is my choice. I feel like the story is even better. It's the only movie that I can remember my husband actually "watching" and not talking the whole time. He even cried during it several times.

For my opinion, its The Notebook. I dont know but when my family watched it. It seems that in interest me than the Titanic.

The notebook was definately more romantic.

It absolutely broke my heart watching it. I couldnt stop sobbing at the end. My boyfriend put me through watching it- so after the movie i told him i hated him for making me watch it:P Lol.

It truely is the most depressing film i've ever seen.

I would have to say that the Titanic was by far the most romantic movie of the two. It had so many elements that just made it better then the notebook. Don't get me wrong, the notebook was really good, but there just did not seem to be that "passion" that Titanic had. Titanic had all the elements of a great romatic film. First it took place in a very romatic time period. Secondly, it had that element of the sinking ship, which keep u guessing as to if they were going to survive or not in the end. It also had the world against them. The families did not approve, and they were literally from different worlds. The one thing that i noticed that was different from the Notebook was the quality of acting(in my opinion no offense) the actors did a great job in titanic of not only making u believe that they were passionately in love with each other, but being able to stay within the time period that actor was f4rom while still being incredibly romantic. The notebook was good, but i did not get the same reaction at the end that i got from titanic. All in all, i think that is what it actually comes down to.. what reaction did you the viewer have when watching the movie. Where u emotionally attached to those characters, or could u just appreciate it on a "romantic film" level.